An in-depth exploration of what is parental alienation—and what it is not
What is Parental Alienation? Imagine this: Jamie, a devoted parent, noticed their eight-year-old daughter withdrawing during their scheduled visits. Once affectionate and excited, she now seemed anxious, hesitant, and spoke in phrases that sounded eerily rehearsed—“Mom says you don’t really care about me,” or, “Dad told me you’re the reason we’re not a family anymore.” Jamie felt heartbreak, confusion, and a profound sense of loss, as if their bond was being quietly eroded by an unseen force. The pain was not just the absence of warmth, but the perception that a loving relationship was being systematically undermined. Jamie’s experience is not uncommon, and it speaks to the deeply human cost of parental alienation.
The Definition of What is Parental Alienation
Exactly what is parental alienation? Parental alienation is a complex and often misunderstood phenomenon. At its core, it refers to a process—sometimes deliberate, sometimes inadvertent—where one parent manipulates a child to reject, fear, or harbor unjustified hostility toward the other parent. This can occur during high-conflict separations or divorces, and it involves repeated denigration, emotional manipulation, and subtle (or explicit) messages that the other parent is unsafe, unloved, or unimportant. The child, caught in a loyalty bind, may begin to distance themselves from the targeted parent, not due to their own feelings or firsthand experiences, but because of the influence of the alienating parent. This process can have lasting psychological effects on both the child and the alienated parent.
What is Parental Alienation and the Top 10 Signs
- The child consistently and unfairly criticizes or denigrates one parent.
- Unjustified fear, anger, or hostility toward one parent, despite a previously healthy relationship.
- Use of adult-like phrases or language that seems rehearsed or borrowed from the alienating parent.
- Lack of guilt or ambivalence about mistreating or rejecting the alienated parent.
- Automatic support for the alienating parent, even in situations where they are clearly at fault.
- The child’s reasons for rejecting the parent are vague, trivial, or unsubstantiated.
- Spreading negative stories about the alienated parent to others (teachers, friends, relatives).
- Refusal to spend time with or communicate with the alienated parent, sometimes even avoiding gifts or letters.
- Hostility extended not only to the parent, but also to the parent’s side of the family.
- Absence of past happy memories with the alienated parent, or sudden rewriting of the relationship history.
What is Parental Alienation Not
It is crucial to distinguish parental alienation from other painful family dynamics that can occur during separation or divorce. Parental alienation is not simply a child expressing discomfort with a parent due to real prior harm or consistent negative experiences. Sometimes, children resist contact with a parent for reasons that are grounded in genuine fear, discomfort, or evidence-based concern for their safety or well-being. In such cases, their reluctance or refusal is not a sign of alienation, but rather a rational response to their lived experience.
Parental alienation is also not present when a child’s relationship with a parent deteriorates due to that parent’s own behaviours—such as ongoing substance abuse, emotional or physical abuse, neglect, untreated or unmedicated mental health issues, or failure to provide a stable environment. In these cases, the child’s avoidance is a natural and protective adaptation, not the result of manipulation by the other parent. It is important that the distinction is made carefully and compassionately, so that true cases of abuse or neglect are not dismissed under the banner of “alienation.”
Unfortunately, the term “parental alienation” is sometimes misused as a weapon by parents who have lost custody or decision-making rights due to their own harmful actions. These individuals might claim they are victims of alienation in an attempt to reverse the narrative—to portray themselves as wronged and to cast doubt on the protective parent. This tactic can be distressing for both the child and the parent who is striving to protect them. In courtrooms and social discourse, the misuse of the term muddies the already complex waters of family law and can place children at further risk if their genuine fears or needs are ignored.
What is Parental Alienation vs DARVO: Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender
One manipulative strategy often observed in these scenarios is known as DARVO—an acronym for Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender. This term describes a pattern where an individual accused of harmful behaviour responds by denying the actions, attacking the accuser, and then reversing the roles of the victim and the offender. In the context of custody disputes, a parent who has engaged in abusive or neglectful conduct might use DARVO to paint themselves as the target of alienation, thereby shifting scrutiny away from their behaviour and onto the other parent. This tactic can have serious consequences, distracting from the child’s needs and safety, and making it difficult for courts and professionals to discern the truth.
Understanding the Motivations Behind What is Parental Alienation
Parental alienation does not arise out of a vacuum; it is often the product of complex psychological, emotional, and relational dynamics. One of the most common motivators is unresolved anger or resentment toward the former partner. When a relationship ends acrimoniously, especially in the wake of betrayal, infidelity, or perceived injustice, some individuals may unconsciously—or at times consciously—seek to punish the other parent by undermining their relationship with the child. The child, unfortunately, may become a pawn in this ongoing conflict, with the alienating parent projecting their own pain, disappointment, or distrust onto the child’s perception of the other parent.
Another significant factor contributing to parental alienation is the presence of certain personality disorders, particularly narcissistic personality disorder (NPD). Individuals with NPD may struggle with empathy and have a heightened need for control, admiration, and validation. For a narcissistic parent, the child’s affection becomes a resource to be monopolized and an extension of their own ego. The idea of “sharing” the child’s love and loyalty with the other parent can trigger intense jealousy and insecurity. To maintain their sense of superiority and control, a narcissistic parent may manipulate the child’s emotions and perceptions, sometimes without conscious awareness of the damage inflicted. In these cases, the child’s independent bond with the other parent is seen less as a healthy relationship and more as a threat to the narcissistic parent’s self-image and dominance.
Social and systemic factors can also play a role in facilitating parental alienation. Some parents, motivated by fear of losing custody or decision-making power, might attempt to sway the child’s allegiance in order to secure their own legal standing. Others may act under the misguided belief that they are protecting the child from harm, especially if their own trauma or biases colour their judgment. In rare cases, extended family members or new partners may contribute to the alienation process, either by reinforcing negative narratives or subtly encouraging loyalty conflicts. Regardless of the underlying reasons, the result is the same: the child’s right to a loving relationship with both parents is compromised, often leaving lasting psychological scars.
Challenges Within the Legal System with Parental Alienation
One of the most significant hurdles in addressing parental alienation lies in the legal system’s lack of comprehensive and consistent legislation regarding what is parental alienation. While many courts recognize the concept of parental alienation, there remains a considerable gap in clear statutory definitions and standardized procedures for identifying and addressing it. Some family court judges don’t give much credence to what is parental alienation and the typical tricks. This ambiguity can result in inconsistent rulings and make it difficult for judges, lawyers, and mental health professionals to intervene effectively when alienation is suspected. Without explicit guidance, the burden often falls on families to navigate a confusing patchwork of precedents and subjective interpretations. As a result, children may remain unprotected, and genuine cases of alienation can be overlooked or mishandled, further complicating already complex custody disputes.
Acting in the Child’s Best Interest
At the centre of any parenting arrangement must be the well-being and best interest of the child. Both parents have a responsibility to foster a loving, supportive and non-toxic environment, while encouraging the child’s relationship with the other parent—unless there is a clear and substantiated risk to safety or welfare. This can be exceptionally difficult in the aftermath of conflict or betrayal, but it remains a core principle of healthy co-parenting. Open communication, respect for boundaries, and a willingness to put aside personal grievances are key to shielding children from adult disputes and giving them the stability they need.
If a parent has a history of poor behaviour—whether due to addictions, ongoing harmful actions, or untreated and unmanaged mental health issues—that places the child in harm’s way, it may be necessary for the courts to limit or revoke their equal rights to custody and decision-making. Though this is a bitter pill to swallow, it is not an act of parental alienation; rather, it is a considered measure made in the best interest of the child’s safety and development. The goal is always to protect the child from harm, not to punish the parent.
In most cases the door is never fully closed to a parent proving their changed behavior. With genuine reform, treatment, and a commitment to personal growth, a parent can demonstrate that they have become a safe, responsible figure in their child’s life. Many legal systems offer pathways for such parents to regain contact, gradually and with appropriate oversight, as long as they can prove that their presence will not jeopardize the child’s well-being.
The Impact of Parental Alienation
Parental alienation leaves deep scars. Children may grow up with distorted views of one parent, struggle with trust and intimacy in later relationships, and carry unresolved grief and loyalty conflicts into adulthood. Its unfortunate too when the client knows first hand what is parental alienation and they long for their affected parent. Alienated parents can experience profound isolation, depression, and a sense of helplessness as they watch their bond with their child dissolve. The emotional consequences ripple outward—affecting families, communities, and even the legal system tasked with protecting children.
Ultimately, the best interest of the child must remain the guiding principle in all family disputes. Children thrive when they are surrounded by love, consistency, and respect—from both parents, whenever possible. When children are able to maintain meaningful relationships with both parents in a safe, supportive, and non-toxic environment, they are given the best chance to grow into resilient, compassionate adults. It is the duty of all adults involved to ensure that children are shielded from adult conflicts, and that their needs are never lost in the shuffle of blame, hurt, or legal wrangling.
About
Heather Caruso is a compassionate, skilled, and intuitive therapist offering in person sessions in Guelph ON and online therapy. She is a registered Canadian art therapist, registered psychotherapist, trauma counselor and narcissistic abuse treatment clinician. She offers a unique blend of therapeutic approaches to help her clients navigate their healing journeys. Heather’s deep empathy and expertise create a safe and nurturing environment for those dealing with a mental health issue. Her areas of expertise are anxiety, depression, grief, low self esteem, stress management, trauma, PTSD and navigating big life changes. Heather offers one on one sessions for people from Ontario.
To support individuals in finding the right therapeutic path for their unique needs, she offers a free Zoom chat where people can ask questions and determine if her therapy services are a good fit for their needs. To book an appointment, click the button below.
